Landlord: screening and leasing to tenants

Tenant screening is the systematic process landlords use to evaluate rental applicants before signing a lease. It involves verifying identity, income, employment, rental history, creditworthiness, and criminal background.

13 steps across 3 sections

1. Popular Screening Services (2026)

  • TransUnion SmartMove / Avail — credit, criminal, eviction; tenant-paid option
  • TurboTenant — free for landlords (tenant-paid)
  • Zillow Rental Manager — integrated with listings
  • Checkr — API-based for property managers
  • Baselane — combines screening with rent collection
  • RentPrep — manual verification option

2. Application Fee Rules

  • California: Capped at actual screening cost (adjusted annually; ~$62 in 2026)
  • New York: Capped at $20
  • Minnesota, Wisconsin: Screening fees allowed but limited
  • Many states: No statutory cap but must be "reasonable"

3. Fair Housing Compliance

  • Race, color, national origin, religion, sex (including gender identity and sexual orientation), familial status, or disability (federal Fair Housing Act)
  • Source of income (Section 8 vouchers) — required in many states and cities
  • Criminal history — many jurisdictions have "ban the box" or "fair chance" housing laws that restrict when and how criminal records can be considered

Common Mistakes

  • Not having written screening criteria
  • Asking illegal questions
  • Using criminal history as an automatic disqualifier
  • Skipping landlord reference calls
  • Not providing adverse action notices

Pro Tips

  • Use a tenant-paid screening service
  • Verify income with multiple sources
  • Call previous landlords, not just the current one
  • Require renter's insurance
  • Document your screening process

Sources

Related Checklists